HALLOWEEN: THE GAME: THE SHAPE IS PERFECT, THE HOUSE NEEDS REPAIRS
6.5 of 10 bananas. Michael Myers feels right. The bugs and the thin story mode do not.
By the Alpha. Post-launch verdict. PS5, Xbox Series, and PC. Launched Sep 8 2026. Updated Oct 10 2026.
Honest note: This replaces my earlier preview and its 8 of 10 score. It is not a fresh hands-on playtest. I built this verdict from launch reviews, critic consensus, patch notes, and what is known about the shipped game. If I put real hours in on stream, I will update the score and say so.
Platforms: The PS5 disc is the Amazon button, in stock at my check. The game launched digitally on September 8, 2026 on PS5, Xbox Series, and PC on Steam, and the Amazon listing dates the PS5 disc to October 6, 2026. Matches shine with other players, so plan on online play.
Get Halloween: The Game for PS5 on AmazonSit with me a moment. My old preview gave this an 8 and said the night looks hungry. It launched in September, and the night turned out hungry and a little broken. When it works, being stalked by a slow, silent Michael Myers is the best horror lobby feeling in years. When it does not, you are stuck in a wall.
What It Wants To Be
IllFonic's asymmetrical horror game, made with John Carpenter's involvement and published with Gun Interactive. It is Halloween night, 1978, in Haddonfield. One player is Michael Myers. Up to four play civilians who warn neighbors, scavenge weapons, guide townsfolk to safety, and call the police. Michael can be stunned or detained, but never killed. A short single player story mode puts you behind the mask.
What Works
The Shape is nailed. Slow stalking, mask POV shots, and Carpenter's score build real dread. The civilian side is about saving people, not just escaping, which gives matches a fresh rhythm. Some critics loved the multiplayer, with GameSpot at 8 of 10 and Game Informer calling the scares and laughs worth it with friends. The October 6 update 1.1.0 fixed crashes, improved performance and NPC behavior, and slowed match pacing to curb objective rushing.
What Breaks
Listen well. Launch was buggy: crashes, players stuck in walls, lost progress. The story mode is a glorified tutorial. Map variety is thin, and asymmetrical games live or die on player counts. Metacritic sits in mixed territory, from the high 50s on Xbox to the low 70s on PC, and only about a third of OpenCritic reviewers recommend it. The first DLC map is due on October 27.
Who Should Play
Play if you have a group of friends and love Michael Myers. Wait for more patches or a sale if you play solo or hate jank. For a single player scare, read my Silent Hill: Townfall verdict.
STRENGTHS
- Michael Myers stalking done right
- Civilian side built around saving neighbors
- Carpenter's score and 1978 mood
- October 6 patch fixed many crashes
HONEST COSTS
- Buggy launch
- Story mode is a short tutorial
- Thin map variety at launch
- Needs a healthy player base
Affiliate note: this Amazon link supports the troop at no extra cost to you. One CTA per review. Platforms listed honestly above.