GamerMonkey logoGamerMonkey.com

Home / Reviews / Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced

ASSASSIN'S CREED BLACK FLAG RESYNCED: THE PIRATE KING RETURNS

Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced PlayStation 5 box art from the Amazon listing
Image credit: Ubisoft, PS5 box art from the Amazon listing the button points to, used for review.

8.0 of 10 bananas. Ubisoft remade the 2013 pirate favorite with new visuals and modern tweaks, and it landed as the best reviewed Assassin's Creed in years. Some critics still call it a remake that did not need to exist.

ActionAdventure

By the Alpha. Full review. Updated Nov 12 2026.

Honest note: This is not a fresh hands-on playtest. I built this verdict from critic reviews, player reviews, the store listing, and the official game pages linked below. If I put real hours in on stream, I will update the score and say so.

Platforms: PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC via Steam. Released July 9 2026, developed and published by Ubisoft. The Amazon button is the PS5 disc. At my Nov 12 2026 check it was sold by Amazon.com at 53.50 dollars and listed In Stock.

Get Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced for PS5 on Amazon

Store check, Nov 12 2026: new copies sold and shipped by Amazon.com at 53.50 dollars, against a 59.99 list price, In Stock. Prices and sellers change, so look before you pay.

Listen well. Ask any old ape in the troop which Assassin's Creed they loved most and half of them say the pirate one. Sea shanties, ship fights, harpooning whales you should not harpoon. Ubisoft heard that for thirteen years. This is the answer.

What It Wants To Be

You are Edward Kenway, a Welsh privateer turned pirate in the Caribbean, who stumbles into the war between Assassins and Templars while chasing gold. You sail your ship, the Jackdaw, fight naval battles, board enemy ships, and explore islands and cities. Resynced keeps that story and map and rebuilds the visuals and many systems for today.

What Works

At my check it sat at 83 on Metacritic for PS5 from 101 critic reviews, and Ubisoft cites an 85 on OpenCritic. IGN gave it 9 of 10 and said it brings Black Flag's systems up to today's standards. Destructoid gave 9 and called it a hallmark of excellence. VGC and TheGamer gave 80s, and Digital Foundry, as quoted by Ubisoft, called it one of the most effective remakes they have seen. Steam players were 84 percent positive across 14,892 English reviews.

What Breaks

The split is real. PC Gamer gave 75 and said it takes away more than it adds. GamesRadar gave 70 and said it cannot decide between faithful and changed. Eurogamer gave 3 of 5. TheGamer says the new graphics cannot hide old open world cracks, dull side activities, and combat that takes hours to get any depth. Game Informer missed the thrill of a new historical setting, which a remake cannot give.

Who Should Play

Play it if you never sailed with Edward, or if you loved the original and want the prettiest way back. Wait for a sale if you own the original and just want new ideas, because this is the same voyage in new sails.

STRENGTHS

  • Sailing and ship fights still rule
  • Big visual rebuild
  • Quality of life fixes
  • Sold by Amazon.com at my check

HONEST COSTS

  • Old open world padding
  • Shallow early combat
  • Critics split on the changes
  • Same story you may know
ALPHA VERDICT: 8.0 of 10. The best way to sail the Caribbean with a hidden blade, and a remake that plays it a little too safe. New players should board. Veterans can wait for a sale. Get Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced for PS5 on Amazon, then meet the troop on Twitch.
Watch on Twitch @gamermonkeydotcomTikTok @gamermonkeydotcomMore verdicts

Related: Assassin's Creed Shadows, Assassin's Creed Mirage, Sea of Thieves.

Sources: Metacritic PS5 critic reviews, Radio Times review roundup, Forbes on the review score, Steam page and user reviews.

Affiliate note: this Amazon link supports the troop at no extra cost to you. One CTA per review. Platforms listed honestly above.